With Wisconsin's win in Hawaii last night, Big Ten football is done for the regular season. At the conclusion of conference play last Saturday, the MVP balloting was already done. 2005 saw co-winners. Quarterbacks Michael Robinson of Penn State, and Brett Basanez of Northwestern shared the honor. While this MVP debate might not have raised the stir the battle of David Ortiz vs. Alex Rodriguez did in American League baseball, this was still a close competition and worthy of little bit more scrutiny.
Robinson was one of the nice stories in college football this year. Having struggled with consistency in his brief spells at quarterback last season (he also played receiver) and early this year, he put it together down the stretch and is right now the best all-purpose quarterback outside of Austin, Texas. His team is co-champs of the conference, BCS-bound, and still has a shot at the national title. His passing numbers of themselves are unimpressive--2,097 yards and 16 TDS are stats that rank well behind names like John Stocco (Wisconsin), Drew Tate (Iowa) and even Blake Powers (Indiana). If you add his 785 rushing yards the numbers look better. More impressive is his 11 rushing touchdown. The running quarterback gives Penn State an added threat in the red zone.
Basanez led the conference in passing yardage, with 3,206. He threw for 19 touchdowns. On a team whose defense often resembled a WAC program he had enormous pressure on him every time he touched the ball. His team went 7-4, and won five conference games--considering the relative status of Northwestern, that is an achievment as impressive as Penn State's comeback year.
There were other worthy contenders. Most notably is Wisconsin's Brian Calhoun. The Badger running back was eliminated in the final two conference games when Penn State and Iowa shut him down, but his resume is dazzling. He led the conference in rushing. He led the conference in scoring. He was a threat out of the backfield, with 563 receiving yards. While his quarterback, Stocco, improved, it is still apparent (particularly against top defenses like Penn State) that Calhoun is who has to carry the UW offense. And the Badger defense, like Northwestern's, played its share of matador football throughout the fall. Calhoun had the pressure on him every time his team got the football.
Michigan State's Drew Stanton was an early front-runner, and still threw for over 3,000 yards, but his team collapsed around him in the final three weeks. Troy Smith at Ohio State will never have to buy a meal in the Buckeye State again, after engineering the dramatic comeback in Ann Arbor last week. But while his numbers are nice (1,940 yards/14TDs passing & 545/11 on the ground) they aren't MVP material.
So it would seem debate would have to center on Robinsion, Basanez and Calhoun. And while "MRob" as Penn State fans affectionately call him (at least I think they're affectionate) has the intangibles that voters like in an MVP--quarterback of a championship team--it's hard to see how he ranks ahead of the other two contenders. Penn State's success is built on a defense that dominates, and a well-balanced offense. Is Robinson a key part of the latter? Absolutely, but there are others to help him carry the load, and the Lion attack is rarely in a positon where they must score. I suspect the current politics of college football, with a wave of Penn State sentiment starting to gain steam, is going to get Robinson to New York for the Heisman ceremony(a fourth or fifth place finish), but the Big Ten's MVP debate should have more properly centered on Basanez and Calhoun.
Both players come to the table as ones who were the undisputed stars of offenses that had to score frequently. The remaining issues would be relative support around them and big-game performance. The first point looks pretty even. Northwestern's freshman running back Tyrrell Sutton ran for 1,390 yards and sixteen touchdowns. Stocco threw for 2,619 yards and nineteen TDs. Calhoun can probably pick up a narrow edge, since he was also a key part of his quarterback's passing numbers.
Each player was shut down in a big road game. Basanez threw for only 121 yards in Columbus. Calhoun was held to 38 rushing yards in Happy Valley. But the Northwestern signal-caller starts to emerge beyond these numbers. Calhoun was completely collared by Iowa (18 yards against a mediocre rush defense at home), whereas Basanez did not have another bad conference game. He cleared the 200-yard mark each time, and went over 300 on five occassions. Calhoun had five 100-yard performances in conference play, and his one other sub-100 yard game (vs. Purdue) was made up for with additional receiving yards. But the Iowa no-show effort is the decisive factor. Based on this, I would cast my vote for Basanez.

http://www.bigtencountry.com